Skip to content

Hiring well

How to compare three local quotes without getting burned

Three numbers that look different rarely describe the same job. Use this line-by-line checklist to compare what each business has actually included.

BizStatoLocal business guidesNov 7, 2026 3 min read

In short

  • A quote is only comparable to another quote once both describe the same scope in writing.
  • The three lines that decide most jobs are exclusions, assumptions and validity dates.
  • Ask which licences, insurance and permits are relevant to the work, and how you can check them.
  • Understand the deposit, payment schedule and cancellation terms before agreeing to a booking.

Start with the scope, not the price

The most expensive mistake in home services is comparing prices for two different jobs. One contractor quotes to replace a failed section of pipe; another quotes to re-pipe the run. Both numbers are honest and they are not comparable.

Before you request quotes, write a one-page scope and send the identical page to every business. Include what is broken, how old it is, the access you can offer, and what you want to be true when the work is finished.

  • The symptom you can see, in your own words, plus when it started.
  • Photos of the area, including the shutoff or panel, so nobody quotes blind.
  • Your building type and age, because code requirements change with both.
  • What finished means: tested, cleaned up, permit closed, old parts removed.
  • Your timing window and whether the space must stay usable during the work.

Put every quote on the same page

When the quotes arrive, rebuild each one as a single table with identical rows. The exercise takes ten minutes and it exposes what a cover page hides. A quote with a lower total often has two rows missing.

If a business will not put a row in writing, treat it as excluded and price the gap yourself before you decide.

  • Measured quantity, for example linear metres of pipe or square metres of decking.
  • Materials with brand and grade, not "standard fixtures".
  • Labour hours, and who supplies what.
  • Permits, inspection fees and disposal, listed separately rather than folded in.
  • Taxes stated as a rate on a subtotal you can verify.
  • Payment schedule with dates and percentages.
  • Warranty length on labour and on materials, written as two separate terms.

Question the three quiet lines

Every credible quote carries three lines that decide how the job ends: exclusions, assumptions and validity. Read them first, because they are where a low number is manufactured.

An exclusion is work the business will not do. An assumption is a condition they expect you to guarantee, such as "existing shutoff is functional". A validity date says how long the price holds. Ask what happens to the price if an assumption turns out to be wrong, and get the answer in the thread so it is written down.

Check the business, not just the number

A tidy quote from a business nobody can identify is not a quote, it is a hope. Two minutes of checking removes most of the risk: confirm the listing is claimed by someone who actually runs the business, and look at when the licence and insurance details were last confirmed.

On BizStato every listing shows who supplied each fact. An unclaimed listing can still be useful, but treat its prices and hours as unverified until the business itself confirms them.

When to walk away

Some patterns are not about price at all. Pressure to decide today, a request for cash, or a deposit that arrives before any written scope are all reasons to keep looking, however good the reviews are.

If something feels off after you have asked a direct question twice and received a vague answer twice, that is your answer.

  • Deposit requested before a written scope exists.
  • No business licence or insurance certificate on request.
  • Payment demanded in cash only, with no receipt offered.
  • A price that changes upward before work begins and is explained as "we will sort it out later".

Next step

Compare listings that show their evidence, then send one request to up to three businesses.

Questions

Related questions